We had a single 250HP OX66 (EFI) engine when we first purchased our Islander (270).
But you should be using the same prop.
Yamaha Saltwater Series 15.25" x 17" pitch.
Or, you could use a PowerTech OFS4R17, which is a four-blade prop in 17" pitch.
Either one should spin up to rated RPM at WOT, and give good performance.
That is a heavy boat for the single engine, so you definitely don't want an aluminum prop.
Brian