Remembering the Edmund Fitzgerald

Fishtales

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2005
Messages
8,033
Reaction score
1,286
Points
113
I don’t know if you remember what happened on November 10, 1975. I was a 7th grader and had a daily afternoon paper route. I spent the early afternoon that day riding my bike, delivering papers with my eyes glued to the story on the front of the Patriot Ledger newspaper published in Quincy MA.

I don’t know what attracted me to the story that day. Maybe it was my family’s history and stories of service in the navy, or that I was always fascinated with boats and large ships, but I remember being drawn to the story that day like a magnet.

I had nearly forgotten about the sinking when about a year or so later a Gordon Lightfoot song came out and I heard it for the first time. I remember liking something about the song but didn’t pay too much to the lyrics. In later years, I figured out that the song was about the Edmund Fitzgerald, I recalled delivering newspapers and being captivated by the story that fall day.

Years past and I forgot all about the wreck. About three years ago, I was reading books and telling stories with my children, when my son asked me to tell him a story about a big boat. They were tired of all those Grady White boat and fishing stories and I needed to come up with something fast. I’ll never know how the story came back so vividly and I told what I remembered that night. The two boys and my youngest daughter were unusually quiet and attentive and asked a lot of questions before going to bed.

The next night, after coming home from work, I grabbed the three of them and we searched the net together. We found some great sites, the lyrics and the music to the song and we got to explore the story of the iron boat named the Edmund Fitzgerald all over again.

This is the best site that I’ve located regarding the building of the ship. It seems unbelievable that one of the largest freighters, built 50 years ago this year by the way, could be almost 730 feet long, over 75 feet abeam and drew 39 feet of water at a cost of $8.5M. She would be a dingy as well as a bargain by the standards of today….
http://www.glmi.org/fitz/

This is a nice little film. Fast forward to 3 minutes into it and watch the next minute or so. It shows the Fitz being side launched. Notice the people on the deck of the ship at launch, it must have been quite an experience when it bobbed like a cork until she settling in the water.
http://www.glmi.org/webcast/archive/fitzvidnoaud.htm

This film details the ships history from launch to wreck and has audio between a ship that was following her and shore just after she was lost. There is also video of her sitting on the lake bed. It is believed that several of the iron ore hatches were breached during the storm and water flooded in on top of the 26,200 tons of iron bound for Detroit for the automobile industry. From what I have read, the ship likely filled quickly with water and the crew never had a chance to abandon ship. It likely sank like a brick in the seas that had built from 10 feet to over 25 feet with wind reaching 90mph by evening. It sank so fast some believe the engines were still running and the prop still rotating – possibly explaining how the prop blades were sheared off the hub by the lake bed.

The only recovered items were a six foot bow section of a lifeboat, a second lifeboat and one PVD. On 7/4/99, the ships bell was retrieved from the wreck site in about 530 feet of water and is currently on display at the Great Lakes Shipwreck Museum. The Edmund Fitzgerald now lays split in two on the lake bed about 170 feet apart, with the bow section upright and the aft end of the ship upside down. No dives are permitted at the site. The ship will never be raised nor its crew recovered.
http://www.glmi.org/webcast/archive/fitzaudvid.htm

This is a decent site dedicated to the 29 sailors who lost their life that day on Lake Superior.
http://www.ssefo.com/info/timeline.html

The final link is youtube video that is pretty cool, set to the Gordon Lightfoot song, edited by Joseph Fulton.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iquCHSkmUek

Every year I look forward to early November to tell the story and the children listen like it is being told for the first time. I still get goose bumps thinking of that day, riding my stingray carrying my paper bag over my shoulder and stopping to read a little more of the story with every paper I delivered. I remember thinking that 29 fathers wouldn’t be coming home to their families and how glad I was that mine was. It is strange how a distant event, where I knew nobody can leave such a mark.

Say a prayer for the crew and their families and hug your kids. You never know when you won’t be coming home.
 

Capt Bill

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Mar 23, 2005
Messages
805
Reaction score
45
Points
28
Location
First State
Model
Sailfish
Thanks, Fishtales, that was a great post, complete with links!

And how cool is that, that your kids love to hear it over again. Precious moments; family bond. Memories for a lifetime.
 

magicalbill

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
314
Points
83
Location
Indiana
Model
Marlin
They had weather reports piped into the wheelhouse as they cruised Eastbound toward Whitefish Point.
Capt. McSorley was in touch with the Capt. of the Arthur Anderson, Bernie Cooper. They stayed, I think 15 miles or so apart and maintained radio contact as the storm approached. The Arthur Anderson was behind the Fitz, I believe.

What I don't get is why didn't they head for Isle Royale, Thunder Bay, or anywhere on the North Shore? That Low Pressure System tracked thru, and the winds veered NW, blowing down the whole fetch of the lake. By the time they made the turn South to head for Whitefish Point, they were exposed to the full expanse of the Lake. They were in following seas probably 20-plus feet high.
They couldn't have been in a worse position on the whole lake. Had they made a turn North out of their shipping lanes, they could've rode it out on the lee shore of Minnesota or Canada.
I guess you had to be in their shoes..Maybe they thought it wasn't gonna be that severe, since they probably rode out many a storm successfully.

May The Lord continue to comfort their families. I have felt the waters of Whitefish Bay from my old Seafarer 22 years ago. Cold as anything I've ever experienced, and that was in August. I can't imagine going down in November out there.
 

catch22

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 14, 2005
Messages
747
Reaction score
5
Points
0
Location
pennsville, nj
Nice post Fishtales.

That video of the launce is pretty cool - http://www.glmi.org/webcast/archive/fitzvidnoaud.htm

I've seen that part on the history channel, (I think?). I believe they said the boat came off too fast, struck the opposite dock and did some damage. They also said a bystander, after seeing it strike the dock, had a heart attack!
 

Drifter80

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2008
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
Points
6
Location
Detroit
Interesting links
I love this kind of stuff. Has anyone seen the freighter that ran aground on South Manitou Island in Lake Michigan? It hit another wreck and lost steering before running aground in the 1960s. The back is broken and it’s in a couple pieces now but you can still see parts of the superstructure above water... although the stink of cormorant bird crap is almost overpowering.
It’s very interesting to see a boat from the “modern age” wrecked up on the shore. There are tons of wrecks in the Manitou passage but as far as I know that’s the only one that is visible from the surface. There are some wrecks in the area that are closer to shore but I've never been able to see any, even on calm clear days.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:South-Manitou-Island-Map.svg
 

magicalbill

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
314
Points
83
Location
Indiana
Model
Marlin
Drifter80;
The wreak on South Manitou is indeed an interesting sight.
The name of the ship was the San Fransisco Morazon..It was a Liberian Steamship that I thought ran aground in the 50's..didn't know it was in the 60's.
When I read it I seem to remember that it was blown onshore on a strong SW wind and grounded where it lays to this day.
I tied off her bow back in '83 and boarded her out of curiosity. The seagull waste that you mentioned was as thick then as it is nowadays, and I almost fell thru the decking when I encountered a rusted section amidships. I guess that's why the Coast Guard doesn't allow random exploration.
 

Drifter80

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2008
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
Points
6
Location
Detroit
It may have been in the 50's when it wrecked. I don't know for sure. Yeah, that would be a dangerous wreck to set foot on. You are more daring than I. Of course maybe it was more intact in the early 80s compared to when I saw it a few years back.
I'm planning on trailering up there again next summer to enjoy some more big lake boating. My family has a cottage in the bay and I'd love to anchor her offshore but I don't trust the weather so I might rent a slip in Leland. Keep her offshore during the day and run her into Leland for the night. We'll see, long time before I have to worry about that.
 

magicalbill

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
314
Points
83
Location
Indiana
Model
Marlin
Drifter..
There is, as you probably know, a great anchorage on the East side of the island. From the Morazon, continue East around past the lighthose and it's a great half-moon cove that is protected in all but East winds.

I anchored my Gulfstream there last summer along with my son's ZX Donzi CC. The water is deep all the way to the beach so you can get your stern close in. We actually lied next to another Gulfstream there and had a "Great Grady" afternoon.
 

Drifter80

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2008
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
Points
6
Location
Detroit
Yeah, that bay is CRAZY deep! Our cottage is on the mainland side in sleeping bear bay. The bay is very sheltered with the dunes and hills but the weather can change very quickly and I don't trust my boat out there over the night. Glen Arbor has a ramp but when the wind is coming out of the northwest you can't put a boat on a trailer. Leland is a safer bet. It would be nice if they put a port of refuge in at Glen Haven but the park service doesn't want that. :roll:
This thread is making me wish I could fast forward to summer :(
 

magicalbill

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Aug 15, 2005
Messages
1,663
Reaction score
314
Points
83
Location
Indiana
Model
Marlin
I'll bet the view from your property is incredible. Your near what I remember as Pyramid Point, I think, South of the Leland breakwater.

Back to the freighters, I have the only positive item from a relationship with my old girlfriend 10 years ago.."Shipwreck History Of The Great Lakes."

It has the story of the Fitz, the Carl D. Bradley, and all the others. What is mysterious to me is the accounts of the "Flying Dutchmen." These are the "lost" ships whose fates were undetermined.

I was particularly intrigued by the accounts of vessels that sailed across Lake Huron in calm seas and balmy weather and were never heard from again. What happened to 'em? How wierd is it to sail away and just vanish?
 

lgusto

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2008
Messages
281
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Location
Midcoast Maine and Florida Gulf Coast
I think all true seamen are like moths to a flame. For me, the most powerful call of the ocean is that it can crush you in an instant without noticing that you ever even existed.
 

Drifter80

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2008
Messages
82
Reaction score
0
Points
6
Location
Detroit
Work keeps me away from these forums far too often. Pyramid point is two peninsulas to our north east. Beautiful spot, I’ve been on the bluffs to watch a storm come in before… amazing.
Sounds like a decent read, I’ll have to raid amazon to see if I can find it.