That's strange.
The understanding I have to this date, is the crap bocking the VST screen (2 micron) is alumiunum oxide from the gas tank being eaten alive by ethanol gas, or occuring after the filter in the motor VST tank itself, perhaps because the VST tank is not grounded, some electrolysis action, or the like, or just sitting in there for some time or in the heat of the sun, involving the ethanol.
That's what I think today, tomorrow's another story.
I doubt your pickups are much different, however, you can swap the fuel hoses to each one and see if the opposite motor is effected.
Something esle I noticed the other day, the starboard motor zinc steering trim adjuster shows galvanic corrosion, not so with the port, both motors are always kept up, or down at the same time. Too bad not both VST had the same off white color crap on them.
And the off white stuff doesn't sink to the bottm, there was a fuel line stain on the VST tank float.