Rick: I suspect that a 250 would be not quite enough. I'm thinking that with your 9'6" beam (I'm presuming that is correct) that your boat is a bit longer and wider than a current 232, which also has the engine(s) out on the bracket. And I would consider a single 250 to be marginal on a 232.
If you're set on a single engine, maybe a Suzuki 300, which weighs about the same as a Yammie F250, would be a better fit. Twins would be a better power choice if the bracket can support the weight.
Rob