To get to the best prop you should do a full performance test first and record your findings as a baseline.
You should record amount of fuel, # of people aboard, sea conditions and temps. You also need to record what prop you are using, where your motor is mounted and the results it netted you. Remember too,
that the height your motor is mounted at has a great effect on a props performance. Sometimes you might have the right prop but it is under performing because your motor is mounted to low. Your anti-ventilation plate should be above the running water surface while on plane (
example). If this is not the case then raise it and see how your prop performs during cruising and top end before jumping into another propeller. Raising the motor can also increase fuel economy...
Here are some of my past recordings to hone in on the right Stainless Prop of one of my Whalers. This is the kind of data you should collect when starting to search for the right set up for your boat.
Example:
Calm water with very light wave action. The air temp was in the low 60's boat was loaded with operator (200lbs) and about 16 to 18 gallons of fuel. The was no wind and the all the speeds were measured on a GPS. The motor on the boat is a 1974 85-HP Evinrude Starfilte V4 turning an aluminum OMC 13x19 aluminum prop with the motor mounted on the bottom hole. I ran the motor trimmed out / up fully with the bow is high. Final two way numbers:
RPM - Boat Speed
2500: 16.3mph
3000: 22.2mph
3500: 28.8mph
4000: 34.5mph
4500: 38.4mph
4650: 39.5mph WOT
Gathering this type of data set will help guide you in the best possible direction on where you need to go and give those professionals who know props the real info they need to get you into the right prop.
For myself I always go to a friend from Continuouswave.com and Thehulltruth.com named Tom W Clark. Is really is a prop guru who knows what prop best fits the boat, motor and mounting height combination for your use. He is a stiletto / turbo prop rep and is a great resource. If would like his contact I would glad to provide it.